How to Measure Church Communication Effectiveness (Without Getting Lost in Analytics)
You could track fifty different metrics. Most of them don't matter.
Open rates, click rates, impressions, reach, engagement rate, bounce rate, follower growth, time on page—it's overwhelming. Especially if you're not a "numbers person."
Here's what actually matters: Is your communication working? Are people seeing it? Are they acting on it?
Five metrics tell you that. Everything else is noise.
The Five Metrics That Matter
1. Email Open Rate
What it measures: How many people opened your email.
Healthy range: 25-40% for most church emails. Above 40% is great. Below 20% is a problem.
What it tells you:
- Is your subject line working?
- Are you sending at the right time?
- Are people interested in your content?
When it's low:
Your subject lines might be generic. "March Newsletter" doesn't compel anyone to open. Try more specific, benefit-driven subjects.
Or you're sending too often. If every email feels the same, people stop opening.
Caveat: Apple's privacy changes have inflated open rates artificially. Track trends over time rather than absolute numbers.
2. Email Click Rate
What it measures: How many people clicked a link in your email.
Healthy range: 2-5% is typical. Above 10% for targeted, relevant sends.
What it tells you:
- Is the content relevant?
- Are your calls to action clear?
- Are you making it easy to take the next step?
When it's low:
Your CTAs might be buried or unclear. Put buttons where people can see them. Use action words: "Register Now," "Watch the Sermon."
Or the content isn't compelling. If people open but don't click, the email didn't give them a reason to act.
3. Website Traffic to Key Pages
What it measures: How many people visit your important pages.
Key pages to track:
- /visit or /new-here
- /events or specific event pages
- /give
- /groups or /connect
What it tells you:
- Are people finding what they need?
- Are your promotions driving action?
- Where are visitors spending time?
Where to look: Google Analytics. Set up a free account if you haven't. Look at the "Pages" report to see which pages get traffic.
Bonus insight: Check mobile vs. desktop. If most of your traffic is mobile (common for churches), your pages better work well on phones.
4. Event Attendance vs. Promotion
What it measures: Did the promotion actually work?
How to track:
After each event, note:
- How many attended?
- How was it promoted (email, bulletin, social, text)?
- When did promotion start?
Over time, you'll see patterns. "Events promoted 3 weeks out get 50% more attendance than events promoted 1 week out."
This is the metric that matters most. Everything else is a proxy. Attendance is the outcome.5. Unsubscribe Rate
What it measures: How many people opted out after your email.
Healthy range: Under 0.5% per email. Above 1% consistently is a warning sign.
What it tells you:
- Are you sending too often?
- Is your content irrelevant?
- Are you annoying people?
When it's high:
Check frequency first. If you're sending 3+ emails a week, that's probably it.
Then check content. Are you providing value, or just asking for things?
What Not to Track (Or at Least, Don't Obsess Over)
Social Media Followers
Growing followers feels good but doesn't mean much. A church with 500 engaged followers beats a church with 5,000 followers who never see your posts.
Focus on engagement rate (likes + comments / followers) rather than follower count.
Impressions
"Our post got 2,000 impressions!" Maybe. But impressions just means it appeared in feeds. It doesn't mean anyone stopped scrolling.
Impressions are vanity metrics. They make you feel productive without telling you anything useful.
Likes
Likes are the lowest form of engagement. Someone tapped once and moved on. Comments and shares indicate much more interest.
Don't optimize for likes. Optimize for action.
The Monthly Check-In
Once a month, spend 30 minutes reviewing your numbers.
The simple dashboard:
| Metric | This Month | Last Month | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email open rate | 42% | 38% | ↑ |
| Email click rate | 4.2% | 5.1% | ↓ |
| Website visits (key pages) | 320 | 290 | ↑ |
| Email unsubscribes | 8 | 5 | ↑ |
You don't need fancy analytics software. A spreadsheet works fine.
What to do with the data:
Celebrate improvements. If open rates went up, something's working. Keep doing it.
Investigate declines. Click rate dropped? Look at your last few emails. Were CTAs clear? Was content relevant?
Don't panic over single-week changes. Trends matter more than individual data points. One bad email doesn't mean your whole strategy is broken.
The Metrics You Can't Track Digitally
Not everything shows up in analytics.
Attendance at promoted events: Did people show up? This requires manual tracking—or a check-in system.
Mentions and word-of-mouth: "I saw that in the bulletin." "Someone told me about the retreat." Keep a running list of these moments.
Anecdotal feedback: When someone says "I love the newsletter" or "I never know what's happening"—that's data. Write it down.
Sign-ups and registrations: How many people registered for events? This tells you whether promotion converted to action.
These analog metrics often matter more than digital ones. A 50% open rate means nothing if nobody came to the event.
Seasonal Patterns to Expect
Numbers fluctuate throughout the year. Know what's normal.
Lower engagement:
- Summer (people traveling, less regular attendance)
- December (holiday overwhelm)
- Holiday weekends
Higher engagement:
- September (back-to-school, new energy)
- January (fresh start mentality)
- Easter season
- Event promotion periods
Don't freak out when summer open rates drop 10%. That's normal. Compare summer to summer, fall to fall.
When to Dig Deeper
Dig deeper when:
- A metric changes suddenly (20% swing in one week)
- A pattern persists for 4+ weeks
- You're launching something new and need to learn
Don't dig deeper when:
- You're just curious (it becomes a time sink)
- One email underperformed (sample size too small)
- You don't have time to act on what you learn
Data without action is just distraction. Only measure what you'll actually use.
The Big Picture
All these metrics ladder up to one question: Is our communication helping people engage with our church?
If event attendance is up, people are getting the message. If visitors are returning, follow-up is working. If giving is growing, the mission is connecting.
The numbers are diagnostic tools, not the point. They help you do better work—which helps people connect to your church and, ultimately, to God.
Don't get lost in the data. Use it to serve people well.
Want to see how your communications are performing—all in one place? bltn tracks engagement across your bulletin, email, and website. Try it free.
